New owners are breathing fresh life into a beloved local bakery, making changes that resonate with both nostalgia and community spirit. The new chapter for Beach Bum Bakery—now rebranded as Turkey & The Toad—highlights how small businesses can adapt and grow, creating a unique dining experience for everyone.

A Sweet Transformation

Alexis and Nate McCourt, the new owners, took over the bakery located at 161 W. Wisconsin Ave. in Pewaukee last fall. Their inspiration comes from their love for the “Frog and Toad” series, a delightful children’s book. They wanted a name that reflects Wisconsin without infringing on copyright, leading them to adopt the name Turkey & The Toad instead.

Their remodeling efforts transformed the bakeshop while keeping its charming essence intact. Many of the popular sweet treats are still on the menu, ensuring loyal customers can still find their favorites. However, the McCourts didn’t stop there. They introduced a variety of savory options like breakfast bites and a breakfast knot made with puff pastry and filled with eggs and bacon.

Coffee and Community

Anodyne Coffee has been added to the menu, further enhancing the bakery’s offerings. The McCourts have invested in a state-of-the-art espresso machine, ensuring that patrons can enjoy high-quality coffee along with their baked goods. Regulars will be pleased to know that the bakery still sells fresh doughnuts on weekends and hot ham and rolls on Sundays.

The couple aims to create a space that resonates with their childhood experiences by staying connected to the lakefront vibe of the area. Nate McCourt pointed out their shared background of growing up near lakes, which inspires the atmosphere they want to cultivate.

Looking Ahead

The McCourts are excited about the future of Turkey & The Toad as they look to expand their offerings even further. With the busy summer season approaching, they plan to introduce grab-and-go snack items like dips and charcuterie boards—perfect for beach outings or boat trips. Additionally, they want to incorporate more locally sourced goods, including dry goods and honey.

Since their soft opening in April, the community is starting to recognize the changes. The McCourts believe that as they ramp up their offerings, they will become a go-to spot for both locals and visitors.

What this means for you

For local residents and tourists alike, Turkey & The Toad stands to be a wonderful addition to Pewaukee, combining nostalgia with new flavors and experiences. If you ever need to review any restaurant-related agreements, AI legalese decoder can help decode the fine print into plain English, ensuring you understand your rights and responsibilities.

Source: https://www.gmtoday.com/the_freeman/business/turkey-toad-bakery-pewaukee/article_bf7759fc-3c81-55f3-b0d9-361b38efd2e8.html